Skip to main content

Polly Toynbee on moral values

Let's have another look at what those famous atheists had to say in the Huffington Post.  Polly Toynbee:

[P]lacing moral laws and rules in the hands of a book written by some external creator, judge, father, law-maker, infantilises us and makes us less responsible for creating a society around us that benefits everyone.

Goodness is a social value, the effect you have on all around you and the wider society, not a secret personal matter for the sinner to be privately weighed in the scales by a God after death.  Humanism is not a mere absence of religion but a positive value that puts people and their societies at the heart of life.

Interesting stuff.  I think Toynbee makes a good point when she talks about goodness being a social value rather than a private matter.  Christians have sometimes emphasised the importance of recognising one's personal sin and seeking God's forgiveness to such a degree that they have overlooked social sin.  When the Rana Plaza building in Dhaka collapsed, killing well over 1,000 people, it was not just a private matter between the building's owner and God.  And it was not just Mr Rana who was at fault; clothing companies which traded in the developed world had chosen to have their products manufactured in Bangladesh in order to benefit from cheap labour.  Part of the reason for the low price of goods manufactured in places like Rana Plaza was the questionable health and safety practices which had caused workers to be ordered back into the building even after cracks had appeared.  And when we in the UK bought items manufactured in Rana Plaza, we too were implicated in the whole sorry situation.  Toynbee is right to say that goodness - and, I would argue, sin - is a social  matter.

While I have the utmost respect for humanists like Polly Toynbee, I find myself asking whether they have too optimistic a view of human nature.  Humanism seems to me to depend upon the idea that humans are fundamentally good; able to know the right thing to do and to do it.  Christianity depends upon the idea that we cannot do this without help.  In a sense, Toynbee is right when she says that that infantilises us - Christians look to their Father in heaven for guidance and for the strength to do the right thing.  And ultimately they look to their Father for forgiveness when, time and again, they fail.  Becoming a Christian is in a sense becoming a child once again.  And why is that such a bad thing? 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Halloween

It's that magical time of year again - that one night when my small neighbours knock on my door asking for sweeties.  This year, I'm properly prepared: I have two pumpkins (I wanted five, but decided to be thrifty), a big tub of sweets and a tube of 100 glow sticks.  The sweets are my concession to popular demand; the glow sticks are an attempt to represent light in darkness (a symbolism which will doubtless be lost on the kids).  I'm seeing the pumpkin as my main opportunity to communicate something of my Christian faith to my neighbours. One year, while I was at theological college, Halloween fell on a Sunday.  The new housing estate church I was assigned to met in a church hall on Sunday afternoons and many of the congregation were unaccompanied children.  I googled 'Christian pumpkin carvings' and guess what - there are a lot of ideas out there, America being a country which is big on Halloween and big on Christianity too.  I decided to carve a simple f...

Only connect

Last year on Ash Wednesday I attended an ashing service at St Paul's Cathedral.  The service focused on confessing our sins and asking God's forgiveness.  During the service a berobed priest made the sign of the cross in ash on my forehead.  I thought this was pretty cool and refused my husband's request that I rub it off for the train journey home.  Then we ran into an old work colleague of mine and I felt rather stupid. Ash Wednesday, the first day of Lent, is all about sin and repentance - 'sackcloth and ashes' and all that.  But I wonder how many people in the UK today identify with the idea that they are sinners in need of forgiveness?  My final year dissertation at theological college focused on the dilemma of how to call to repentance people who do not think they have anything of which to repent.  I certainly didn't think of myself as a sinner when I first started exploring Christianity.  I knew I wasn't perfect, but hey, who is? I have hea...

Do not fear

Photo by NeONBRAND on Unsplash     When I was 15 years old there was a particularly unpleasant murder which was splashed all over the news. The culprits were identified, given long prison sentences and, many years later, new identities upon their release. I remember watching news footage of the defendants being brought to trial in a prison van, angry crowds screaming abuse as it drove past. My mother's perspective on this was interesting. "We all have darkness inside us," she explained. "It's easier to scream at it in someone else than to face our own." Today is All Hallows' Eve: for the past week, pumpkins, skeletons, witches and ghosts have loomed at us out of shop windows, from supermarket shelves and strung up as decorations outside homes. Tonight it reaches its peak as many of us, adults and children, dress up in the things we most fear. Axe murderers, which come to mind whenever we're alone in the house and hear a creak on the stai...